How NOT to say something racist about what’s happening in Baltimore

Following the death of yet another unarmed Black man at the hands of police and the continuing protests in Baltimore, many white people are struggling to make comments on social media without saying something racist.  Most of these comments aren’t intended to be racist or offensive, and many are made in good faith, but that doesn’t make the comments any less racist or problematic.  To help white people navigate the difficulties of talking about race, here is a guide for not saying something racist.

Know your place.  There’s no reason why anyone should listen to what you have to say.  Your opinion doesn’t matter, because you have no idea what it’s like to be black in the most recent city to have police kill an innocent black person.  Your opinion matters slightly more if you can actually demonstrate that you genuinely want the movement to succeed — most criticism of how people are protesting (in Baltimore and Ferguson and everywhere else) very clearly is coming from people who would find something to criticize no matter what.  Most white people (and most people of color, too) who support the movement and seem to defend rioting and looting really don’t endorse rioting or looting, and themselves would never do either, but they realize that it’s not for them or others to denounce.  We’re used to being able to speak and have others listen to us, but it is obviously inappropriate for white people to be dominating the conversation about an issue that primarily affects black people.  Most media commentators have been white, and when black people are interviewed, the discussion revolves around demands by the white person that the black person denounce rioting or endorse the narrative of protest that the interviewer is pushing.  (See, for example, Wolf Blitzer’s interview of Deray McKesson)

Don’t assume that the people whose action you disagree with aren’t also attending the more peaceful protests and vigils, don’t vote, don’t do community organizing work, and don’t volunteer.  It’s an assumption about who they are as people that, simply, you don’t know and don’t know anything about.  You don’t know what struggles they’ve faced or what else they’ve done to bring about change.

Don’t assume that the people who are protesting police violence aren’t also concerned with gang and inter-personal violence in their own communities.  Most of them are.  Some of them aren’t.  But those discussions are had within those communities, and they have no obligation to include you in those conversations or inform you that they’re taking place.

Don’t assume that police-on-black violence and black-on-black violence have anything to do with each other.  They are both certainly rooted in a history of racism and oppression, but more immediately the causes are different, and they need to be dealt with differently.  People in those communities have a better idea than you how they are affected by both types of violence, and what to do about it.  People in those communities also have a right to decide how to prioritize the multitude of problems they’re facing — you, as an outside white person, have no business deciding for them.

Don’t assume that you’re an expert on social movement history or theory or that you know better what strategy Black people should follow, and don’t assume that the people in the streets aren’t experts.  Your understanding is probably wrong, unless you’ve actually studied social movement history and theory, because white people (all people, really) are taught a largely made-up history about the civil rights movement throughout K-12.  This history was written by white people, and ignores so many people and events that brought the results that we credit MLK for, and erases the people and ideologies that disagreed with the goals of the civil rights movement for something more revolutionary.  This assumption also relies, in turn, on the assumption that the Black protesters haven’t spent time reading or learning about their own history and aren’t educated.  A not-insignificant number of protesters are college students, and some may even be graduate students or professors or authors, and many of those who lack formal education have carried out their own independent study.

Don’t assume that nonviolent protest is the only way that change has been brought about.  See above.  Most anti-colonial struggles were won after years of intense warfare, and most nonviolent movements occurred against the backdrop of or threat of armed conflict.  The majority of civil rights movement participants carried guns for self-protection, and while MLK himself didn’t carry, he had guns in his house and armed bodyguards outside of his house.  A main reason why MLK rose to prominence and is considered a legitimate leader today is because he was more palatable than the Black Panthers, Black Liberation Army, and others like Malcolm X who were calling for more aggressive measures.  Again, calling on Blacks to protest peacefully is claiming that you, as a white person, have a right to make decisions for Black people.

Don’t assume that what worked 50 years ago will work today.  The civil rights movement protested laws that limited their rights and freedoms, and those laws could be protested by breaking them — civil disobedience.  What laws are there today?  Such laws are gone now, and, as well all know, all Americans, regardless of race, are equal on paper, but actual practical equality has never existed.  What exists now is much more insidious, a culture that perpetuates racism and structural inequality, that can’t be fixed by a single piece of legislation or policy change.  Body cameras won’t stop the killing of black people by police (Eric Garner), nor will the prosecution of police (Rekia Boyd).  As white people, we are able to address most of our grievances through legislation, even if our campaigns aren’t always successful.  As members of the dominant social group, we have the power to shape the broader culture.  Black people have been increasingly disenfranchised since the civil rights movement, losing the vote through voter ID laws, felon restrictions, gerrymandering, and frequent irregularities, and with it the ability to affect changes that can be legislated.  As arguably the least powerful social group in our country, Blacks have limited ability to challenge and change a culture that perpetuates racial stereotypes and prejudices.  We also need to recognize that the civil rights movement, and similar movements, have been studied at length in order to prevent the success of replica movements.

Don’t quote Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. at protesters.  Chances are, you’re quoting him out of context — he was publicly against denouncing riots, period.  It assumes that you are more well-read than them (you probably aren’t).  It also imposes on them your way of thinking, because you’re probably selecting quotes that you already agree with.  It also ignores that we admire a number of white men as a society who used violence to solve their problems, e.g. Washington, Jefferson, Lincoln, FDR, etc., so it creates a double standard where it’s ok for white people to be violent, but not for black people.

Don’t assume that MLK provides the only legitimate model for protesters.  When Wolf Blitzer demanded of Deray McKesson, “I just want to hear you say that there should be peaceful protests, not violent protests in the tradition of Dr. Martin Luther King,” this is an example of white people deciding for black people how they should express their anger and how they should try to create change.  White people can choose any number of white leaders who have often contradictory positions.  It’s why we have primary elections – because people who are often fundamentally in agreement on political goals also often disagree on the specific goals or means to carry them out.  Black people should be able to choose their own heroes and role models, just as white people are encouraged to do.  Some will choose MLK and Rosa Parks, but others will find that the ideas of Malcolm X or Huey P. Newton or Assata Shakur or Marcus Garvey are more appropriate or accurate in the current situation or for their own personal experiences, or they may even choose to follow someone who isn’t Black.

Don’t assume that rioting accomplishes nothing, or that it’s mindless.  See above re: social movement experts.  Some people are angry and the only way they can think of, or the only option they have open to them, is to break windows.  Some people are trying to take advantage of the situation for their own goals, which are usually either to avenge grievances they have against the store and its personnel or to materially improve the quality of their lives.  And so what?  Black people, just like everyone else, are told that their self-worth is measured by the possessions they have.  If you’ve grown up your whole life in a system of oppression and have worked hard since you were a kid but couldn’t save up enough money because of the demands of being poor, but now you have the opportunity to steal a pair of Nikes that will make you feel more like a human being, why wouldn’t you?  Or if you can steal food or toiletries that you and your family need?  Or maybe you’ve been ripped off by the check-cashing place down the street every week for your working life because there’s no banks in your neighborhood and no real regulation of a predatory industry, and you have a chance to cut into their profits.  Or maybe, after a lifetime of you and your friends and family being messed with by the police, you have a chance to throw something at them and feel just a little bit less powerless.  Everyone has different reasons for participating, and as white people we have no right to judge anyone for their own reasons.  You don’t have to agree with it, and you don’t have to do it yourself, but you don’t get to say that black people don’t deserve new shoes, that they shouldn’t be able to put food on their tables, that they shouldn’t do what they can to make a better life for themselves and their families, or that they shouldn’t be allowed to take action against people who have taken advantage of them.  As white people, we have so many more resources than black people do to accomplish these goals without rioting.  (See, for example, Ta-Nehisi Coates’ article in The Atlantic)

Don’t assume that black people would be treated any differently if they acted differently.  The subtext is the assumption that they would be treated like white people if they acted like white people.  White people also do dumb stuff around cops but don’t get shot; white people aren’t getting killed at nearly the same rate while unarmed, and white people aren’t even getting killed as often as unarmed black men when they point loaded guns at police.  Clearly, something else is going on.  It’s easy to point to a few cases like Mike Brown or Tamir Rice who, if we take police reports as true, possibly could have done things differently (not that they should have been shot and killed anyway); but there’s also nothing that Akai Gurley, John Crawford, Sean Bell, Eric Garner, or Rekia Boyd could have done to avoid being killed by police.  But this is perhaps beside the point: black people shouldn’t need to act how white people want them to act just to survive in this country, and it ignores the salient issue of racial bias.

Don’t assume that Freddie Gray’s (or Michael Brown’s or Tamir Rice’s parents’) criminal record is relevant.  It’s not, unless you’re willing to also talk about the records of the police involved.  But, even then, it’s still not.  In many of these shootings, the person wasn’t committing a crime when they were stopped by police and shot; in some cases, like Gray’s, it’s not even clear why they were stopped at all.  Even if they were suspected of committing a crime then, their past record has no bearing on their guilt in that crime or punishment the police can mete out, and, unless they were posing an imminent threat to the lives of officers present or to other civilians, force is not warranted, much less deadly force.  The purpose of bringing up the record (which, unsurprisingly given modern policing, most black men have) is to smear a dead person and justify their death.  This is never done for white people, and no one would dare say that any other type of murder or homicide victim deserved to be killed — we should think about why it’s only ok to say that about black men and women killed by police.

Don’t assume that, as a white person, you’re not part of the problem.  No, no one’s blaming you for slavery, or for segregation, or for the murder of Freddie Gray.  But all of these things, whether explicitly or not, were done in our name.  We all profit from racism, even if we’re dirt poor — imagine a black person in your exact situation, and all of the additional challenges and predations they have to deal with every day.  Let’s not also forget that class and gender and other social statuses are important in how we all experience daily life, but it’s difficult to argue that things wouldn’t still be harder if we were Black.  Most of us have an ancestor who made money off of slavery, and that has contributed to the opportunities that we have had in life, even if only nominal.  Segregation and other discriminatory practices also ensured that our ancestors had access to better homes, better schools and further schooling, better jobs, better and cheaper food, better financial opportunities, and so on.

Don’t assume that it’s the job of people of color to teach you about racism or to take the time to respond to your comments or debate you.  This is a very difficult time for many people of color who are feeling like their lives are considered worthless by the society they live in, and who are seeing people that look like them or their friends or family members killed by police with impunity.  The last thing they want or need is someone trying to argue with them or tell them that how they feel about this situation is wrong.  Very likely, however, if you ask people of color questions about how they’re feeling or what you can do, they will be receptive, especially if it’s someone you have a personal relationship to.  But also don’t take it personally if they’re not.  Racism works as a tax on people of color, especially black people — getting to work takes longer; food costs more; more of their income goes to cashing checks, the police, housing, and everything else than it does for us; schools aren’t as good; jobs pay less; and there is a cumulative daily stress that goes with dealing with a considerable number of even minor or nominal acts of discrimination or bias throughout the day.  It doesn’t make sense that, on top of all of this, they have to take more time out of their day to explain to us the racism that they experience — we’re more than capable of doing our own research, reading the books and articles that have been written, and paying attention in our own life, to learn about racism and how it works.  We shouldn’t be imposing yet another tax on black people.

Don’t expect social change to be comfortable or convenient.  Little has changed since the civil rights movement, and life is not comfortable or convenient for people of color in this country.  For people of color to be treated equal to whites, we’re going to lose some of our relative status.  It would mean that, all else being held constant, some white people would now be at the very bottom of the economic structure.  But many people involved in the protests don’t want that — they want an economic system that doesn’t prey on anyone or exploit anyone for their labor, a political system that responds to the needs of all people, and police that protect and help all people equally.

Do listen, without judgment, to the stories and experiences of people of color.  Listen to and read what they have to say, and try to understand where they’re coming from.

Do think about how your life intersects with that of the protesters — what you have in common, what shared interests you have, what you could unite on.

Do ask how you can get involved.  Really, the best thing you can do now is talk to people and listen.  You can also read books about Black history — you can ask a librarian for suggestions, but a few good, accessible starting points are The Wages of Whiteness, by David Roediger, Kindred, by Octavia Butler, Black Like Me, by John Howard Griffin, or To Kill a Mockingbird, by Harper Lee.

Can Racist Speech Really be Confronted by More Speech? FIRE’s Speech Codes and the Empathic Fallacy

In response to an event at the law school sponsored by the Federalist Society and the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education in opposition to campus prohibitions on oppressive speech, I posted a rather long, and immediate, response.  In quick summary, I pointed out that FIRE and the Federalists conflate several types of speech, ignoring dissent to take up the cause of allowing white students to use racial slurs against students of color who have been historically and presently excluded from the university and subjected to structural oppression and microaggressions in their daily lives.

Additionally, it should be noted that Sevcenko’s solution to racism is for those oppressed to argue back.  Essentially, they are arguing for a tax (in time, effort, and emotional resources) on the oppressed to benefit (through education) the oppressors.  In other words, FIRE’s free-market approach to speech is inherently dependent upon colonialism.

But, colonialism also requires a certain social ordering, and there are consequences for defying that order.  We can point to numerous examples where an oppressed person talked back and was harmed for doing so (just look at the history in this country of lynchings and gay-bashings).  That is, assuming the person using oppressive language was courageous-enough to use it in person, and not carve it into someone’s dormroom door, or spraypaint symbols on cultural centers.

I decided to revisit these issues after coming across a relevant passage from Richard Delgado and Jean Stefancic’s Critical Race Theory: An Introduction (2001):

Consider, next, how in certain controversies, for example, the one over hate speech, a particular type of tough-minded participant is apt to urge a free-market response: if a minority finds himself or herself on the receiving end of a stinging remark, the solution, it is said, is not to punish the speaker or enact some kind of campus hate speech rule, but to urge the victim to speak back to the offender.  “The cure for bad speech is more speech.”

One difficulty with this approach is that it may be physically dangerous to talk back.  Much hate speech is uttered in several-on-one situations where talking back would be foolhardy.  At other times, it is delivered in anonymous or cowardly fashion, such as graffiti scrawled on the bulletin board of a minority association, or an unsigned note left in the box of a student of color.  In these instances, more speech is, of course, impossible.

But a more basic problem is that much hate speech is not perceived as such at the time.  The history of racial depiction shows that our society has blithely consumed a shocking parade of Sambos, coons, sneaky Japanese, and indolent, napping Mexicans–images that were perceived at the time as amusing, cute or, worse yet, true.  How can one talk back to messages, scripts, and stereotypes that are embedded in the minds of one’s fellow citizens, and, indeed, the national psyche?  The idea that one can use words to undo the meanings that others attach to these very same words is to commit the empathic fallacy–the belief that one can change a narrative by merely offering another, better one–that the reader’s or listener’s empathy will quickly and reliably take over.

Speech Codes and the Right to Intimidate: Criticizing FIRE and the Federalist Society’s Defense of Racial Slurs

Earlier today, the Federalist Society and the American Constitution Society sponsored a speaker affiliated with FIRE, the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education, Catherine Sevcenko, a graduate and professor at George Mason School of Law.

On it’s face, FIRE’s mission and rhetoric are compelling; after all, it seeks to expand free speech rights at schools and colleges. This shouldn’t seem too objectionable, given that I’ve accumulated 13 student conduct charges related to criticism of my old university’s administration (which I mention lest any reader think I’m sympathetic to school administrations or student codes of conduct). Obviously, free speech on campus is a major issue, with stringent time and place restrictions, frequent arrests of (leftist) protesters, and occasional suppression of leftist groups’ flyers posted in accordance with campus policy. It is nothing new to this country, but there are de facto content-based restrictions on student speech throughout public and private education, from middle school through graduate and professional school. And, of course, the content that is most regulated is that of leftist and progressive groups, and those most critical of administrations’ failure to deal with problems affecting historically marginalized and underrepresented groups of students.

FIRE does tackle this suppression of speech–sometimes. FIRE’s real mission, though, is the abolition of speech codes which give schools additional power to stop and punish “hate speech” (loosely defined). The precise title of the presentation was “Why we shouldn’t stop hate speech.” Not, “Why we shouldn’t criminalize or punish hate speech,” but instead, in effect, why we should force universities to allow it.

Not all of Sevcenko’s points were bad. After all, often the best way to discredit an offensive or oppressive idea is to let the idea-holder open their mouth. Other times… allowing a hateful idea to be discussed and gain traction can have disastrous results, as much of Europe discovered 75 years ago, and is rediscovering today. Naturally, FIRE condemns speech which incites violence, but there is certainly a slippery slope or critical mass argument that could be made here.

What concerns me most about Sevcenko’s presentation, apart from the consequences of allowing hate speech, is the conflation between dissent against public authorities and speech originating from the most privileged sections of society toward those who are among the historically most oppressed and marginalized, using language which directly references and contributes to that oppression.

Sevcenko here argues that allowing bigots to speak allows identification of the person and also an opportunity to dialog with them and others. This seems asinine if you’ve ever tried to discuss white privilege with a racist relative. Naturally, when something offensive is said, it should be responded to (in exactly what way I’ll leave up to those offended by it); it can be an effective way to inoculate others against this speech and open up space to discuss the structural systems of oppression that enable such speech. But this burden is being placed squarely on the shoulders of those who already face so much systemic and individual oppression in their daily lives. That they should be forced to accept more oppression, and take more time out of their lives to confront this is quite apparently a real consequence to FIRE’s mission that those not attuned to racism would forget or ignore.

Universities in part keep these speech codes in a perhaps futile attempt to create a safe space for such marginalized and underrepresented students to focus on their studies and create some value for their communities. Dismantling these codes takes away this buffer and will inevitably harm the ability of students of color and queer and trans students especially to complete their education.

And, whether intentional or not–that an organization which admires Justice Scalia sponsored Sevcenko is suggestive–this is the point. It’s not about freedom of speech for all. It’s about the freedom of the most advantaged students to oppress less advantaged students with their words, distract them from one of the few venues available for them to build social capital and advance in the class structure, remind them that their ancestors were owned (because, yes, even early Latino and Asian “immigrants” to this country were effectively enslaved), and remind them most of all of who continues to have the most power in society.

With this critique in mind, there is one other important observation to make. Sevcenko did not cite a single case where a student at any level or type of institution had been charged for hate speech. Those who studied in the UC system between 2009 and 2012 will remember a stark contradiction: around 200 students were brought before disciplinary bodies on student conduct charges related to criticism of the administration’s budget cuts (though not under speech codes); at the same time, there were so many clearly racist and otherwise oppressive incidents throughout the UC system with few if any students similarly charged. Between the nooses at UCSD, the “pilgrims and indians” party at UCI, the “Asians In the Library” video at UCLA, the female students who had ethnic slurs carved into their apartment door near UCLA, a swastika painted on the side of USCS’s LGBT center, and so on, there is a pattern of conduct much more vile than basic “hate speech” being permitted. Add to those examples the constant experience of students of color being called every racial term imaginable by white students with impunity, and a quite different picture of the “danger” of speech codes emerges.

Sprinkled throughout the presentation were references to political dissidents, foreign celebrities making Islamophobic remarks, and one case involving a student who was never actually disciplined, but merely asked by an administrator to not wear a shirt reading “We get you off for free” in connection with an organization he was involved with, Students Defending Students at Ohio State University. (Read the complaint filed by FIRE here) The only actual hate speech cases brought up were cross-burning cases, including R.A.V. v. City of St. Paul, in which white teenagers burned a cross on the lawn of a black family, and Scalia, not coincidentally, wrote the opinion, implying that somehow this wasn’t a racially-targeted incident. R.A.V., just like the incidents throughout the UC, was fundamentally about intimidation and oppression, not “speech.” The only idea being conveyed by a burning cross is, “remember when this accompanied lynching? Get back in your place or we’ll hang you from a tree.”

What was discussed more was repression of dissent. It should go without saying that dissent is not the same as hate speech. It should also go without saying that invoking the repression of dissent to claim that hate speech codes are repressive is over-reaching and even ridiculous, but this was the tactic used by Sevcenko to create the impression of a real crisis. Without actual cases of hate speech codes restricting valid speech, there is no purpose to rescinding these codes besides opening the floodgates to more oppressive speech on our campuses.

While on it’s face an admirable proposition–free speech for all, who doesn’t want that?–FIRE’s project, at least in regards to speech codes, is much more insidious: it is really about maintaining and advancing white supremacy, by slowly giving white students more power over students of color, and keeping the door shut on students of color when they demand that their school administrations do something about the harassment and intimidation that they face.

There are serious restrictions on free speech on campuses and elsewhere in our country.  Protest is criminalized, and dissidents are sitting in jails.  There is also significant and continuing repression against people of color everywhere in the US.  Under the guise of free speech, FIRE would have us ignore this repression and instead have us tilt at their windmills, helping them and the Scalias roll back the rights and advancements of people of color.

The Need for (More) Legal Services

“They’re certainly entitled to think that, and they’re entitled to full respect for their opinions,” said Atticus, “but before I can live with other folks I’ve got to live with myself. The one thing that doesn’t abide by majority rule is a person’s conscience.”

I recently lost my job as a union organizer, and while I’m receiving unemployment benefits I’ve been volunteering at an anti-eviction law office in San Francisco, the Eviction Defense Collaborative. Volunteers and law students there do intake of clients who have received various eviction notices, and assist attorneys in preparing motions and case files. I haven’t been there long, but nearly everyone I’ve talked to thinks it’s one of the best places to intern/volunteer, because of the amount of attention, trust, and training that’s given to volunteers. I already have a feeling that I’ll have a significant advantage during my 1L year (and beyond) because of the hands-on legal training I’m receiving there.

I’ve now been working there over a month, but on Friday I had a really touching moment with a client, where during and after I repeatedly told myself, this is why I want to be a lawyer. This elderly man from the South came in with a Sheriff’s Notice; he had previously been in our office with a summons and complaint (based on a nuisance complaint), reached settlement with the landlord’s attorney (without his own attorney there), and allegedly breached behavioral stipulations, partly as a result of the landlord’s actions. Our office filed a motion in opposition to the landlord’s ex parte request for default judgment, but we were unsuccessful and judgment was entered. Now, two weeks later, he had received a notice that gave him four days to vacate before the Sheriff came to evict him.

Like many of our clients, this man had significant mental and physical disabilities; he has cancer and likely has a pervasive developmental disorder (PDD) or learning disability, quite possibly a mid-functioning type of autism. He has a social worker and receives all of his income from Social Security and EBT. Fortunately, we’re able to assist folks like him, who would have nowhere else to go otherwise. At this point in his case, all we can really do is prepare paperwork for him to request a stay in court; we offer limited scope representation for our clients, who often appear in pro per with our motions. This man will at least have his social worker in court with him. Hopefully, he will receive the stay and, with help from the Thanksgiving holiday, will postpone his eviction for two weeks–unfortunately, there’s not much else we can do for him, but this will buy him and his social worker enough time to find new housing.

It was a profound moment for me, talking with this man, because he wasn’t there because he forgot to pay rent; he wasn’t there because he was violent; he wasn’t there because he was a nuisance to his neighbors. He was there because the entire deck was stacked against him, and when he finally lost despite his best efforts, and the best efforts of a team of people supporting him, and losing for him meant losing most of his belongings and being thrown out on the streets, right before the start of Winter, with cancer and other health problems. That isn’t to imply that the deck isn’t stacked in those other cases, and I of course wouldn’t be volunteering at EDC if I didn’t think that everyone should have decent housing, no matter what their ability to pay, what mistakes they’ve made in their life, what their mental or emotional state is after a life of suffering. Capitalism–and its myriad of related systems of oppression–is the primary reason why the EDC is necessary. What this client ultimately appreciated most, knowing he was likely to lose, was how I/we treated him. I told him repeatedly that we would do everything we could for him, while being honest about his situation, but I also told him that no matter what the landlord has accused him of, no matter what he has done, he didn’t deserve to go through this. He’s tried hard to make the best of difficult circumstances, and he deserved to have a roof over his head. And while the system is turned against him, I/we would be there at his side. At the end of the day, sometimes that’s all we can do. And, as I also came to realize while working as a union rep and organizer, that’s often all people are looking for. When they’re served with an eviction notice or termination letter, they come to expect the worst. And anything we can do to make things less worse for them can mean the world. Even just having someone believe their side of things, to vindicate their feelings and experiences, can mean more than actually beating their case.

What is perhaps more profound from this interaction is the realization that, while things have come a long way nationally, San Francisco is almost utopian compared to the rest of the country. If the deck is stacked here, imagine what it’s like in less-progressive cities. And the existence of an EDC is very rare. Most other big cities have some services available, but San Francisco is at the head of the pack when it comes to its treatment of the poor (but is still quite abysmal). My client told me that, in some ways, he wished he’d never left his home state and come here; while he may never have ended up in this situation down South (cheaper rent and family support being the main reasons), these services simply do not exist there.

The South, after all, spawned Powell v. Alabama, Gideon v. Wainwright, Harper Lee’s To Kill a Mockingbird, and John Grisham’s A Time to Kill. The poor regularly receive inadequate legal services, even in criminal cases following Gideon. See, for example, “Gideon‘s Promise Unfulfilled: The Need for Litigated Reform of Indigent Defense” in Harvard Law Review, and the work of Gideon’s Promise (formerly the Southern Public Defender Training Center), which is working to strengthen indigent defense in the South. Gideon’s Promise also places and trains law students–worth bookmarking for your 1L and 2L summers if public defending is in your range of interests. The ABA and other organizations have also documented failings and called for reforms to indigent defense in the South; and we only have to look at the recent trial of George Zimmerman for the murder of Trayvon Martin to see just how the Southern justice system functions.

This is what is driving my decision to go to law school, and what will motivate me to put up with and power through the dehumanizing law school experience, miserable job market, and stressful application process. As Scott Turow (One L) and Richard Kahlenberg (Broken Contract) have sufficiently demonstrated, law school tends to push students into corporate careers–if not servicing corporate clients outright, then working for for-profit firms–rather than the areas where there’s most need for lawyers: in public interest, public defense, and legal services. There are some tremendous attorneys and advocates fighting for the oppressed and downtrodden in the South, and everywhere else in this country for that matter, but there are far too few. San Francisco and other big cities that already provide a selection of services still need more good people, and other cities and rural areas need even more. And I hope to be one of them, wherever I end up.

Rethinking the Legal Curriculum

As I finalize applications, my top choice in schools has turned out to be Georgetown University Law Center. While it’s an elite, Jesuit college in the nation-state’s capital, it has one of the most innovative school curricula in the country. Northeastern University Law School, another top contender for my choice, is well-known for their alternative 2L/3L Co-op program, but Georgetown offers what is called “Curriculum B” for their 1Ls.

According to GULC, “Curriculum “B” was developed in 1991 by a faculty committee charged by the Dean to comprehensively rethink the first year of law school and offers an innovative and integrated approach to the study of law.” Another, well-hidden, document on the GULC website offers a great deal more information, including course descriptions:

The curriculum is designed to respond to three important changes in legal practice and theory in the years since the standard curriculum was developed Curriculum B emphasizes different material that is organized in a manner that promotes the coordination and integration of the various classes.

First, the emergence of the regulatory state and of pervasive regulation in most areas of the common law has transformed the nature of legal practice. Today, many legal problems are national or international in scope, rather than merely local. Often, Congress or a regulatory agency, rather than a court, determines the underlying rules.

Second, the traditional doctrinal boundaries between common law subjects like torts, contracts, and property have broken down. Common law rules in all three areas are increasingly seen to present common problems of incentives, distribution, and social control.

Third, other disciplines — especially economics, philosophy, history, and political science — have had an important influence on the manner in which modern lawyers think about and practice the law.

I wanted to also share the “Section 3 Manifesto”, put out by the Curriculum B students a few years ago, and shared by the Scoplaw blog. Scoplaw also has a number of resources about Section 3/Curriculum B. Continue reading →

Eo Ipso — Why?

The LSAT is behind me, applications aren’t online yet, and law school is 14 months away. So, why am I starting this now?

I’ve spent several years now thinking about law school and a legal career. During that time, I’ve met a handful of good progressive or leftist lawyers and law students, who I’ve been able to work on legal projects with, and have convinced me that there is a place for a leftist in the law.  But when you consider that the Bay Area alone produces, what, 1500-2000 JDs every year, a handful isn’t very much. Then again, if you are a leftist, you’re already used to standing virtually alone in a complacent society. To make a long story short, there’s a real need for leftist lawyers, who don’t take the law for granted, who are committed to serving the poor and oppressed, who see the law as both a tool and a barrier to achieving justice.

But this blog? Well, as best I can tell, there really isn’t anything out there for rabble-rousers who are considering law school. For example, as someone who was mass-arrested at the RNC, who violated the Mexican Constitution to work with anarchist and magonista collectives in Oaxaca, who’s been arrested and even prosecuted for a number of protest-related crimes, who’s trained in unarresting, how do I write a personal statement? How do I convince law schools that I now have respect for the rule of law, even if I don’t? Do I emphasize that year I was in student government and wrote resolutions and sat on policy committees, or my professional experience with labor law? Or do I write openly about my experiences with the law, but also talk about the lawyers I worked with, and how I think I can contribute to social change as a juris doctor?

Contrary to a guide I spent way too much time reading, for libertarian (i.e. so-called “anarcho-capitalist”) law students which decried the abundance of left-wing extremists in the faculty at conservative schools, actual left-wing extremists are neither common nor encouraged. I’m not sure how my application will be received. Hopefully my letters of recommendation from lawyers I admire, my decent LSAT score, and modest GPA will sway admissions committees if my personal history doesn’t. On the other hand, wouldn’t someone who has, himself, been through the criminal injustice system, even spent time in jail, make a damn good defense attorney? Wouldn’t someone who, with Mexican comrades, ran from paramilitaries to avoid being beaten, jailed, and deported become a tireless human rights lawyer, with the right training?

In an ideal world, I would be an admissions officer’s dream. But law school is more complex than merely attracting the best students and faculty. Rankings, tuition, bar passage rates, and placement rates trump commonsensical factors. And these are so gamed, with scandals every year about falsified statistics (throughout higher education).

I don’t fully know how this admissions process will play out, how I’ll fare in law school, or where I will end up afterwards. But as I continue onward, I hope to record my observations and insights here, in the hopes that others will be able to more easily follow.